Against the Current, No. 245, November/December 2026
-
Confronting Rampant Repression
— The Editors -
Different Soil, Similar Weather & Familiar Seeds: Serbia to Minnesota
— Mihailo Vučetić -
America's Detention Nightmare
— Suzi Weissman interviews John Washington - France's Student Eruption
-
A Month to Prepare for the General Strike
— Kit Adam Wainer -
Indian State Wages War on Citizens
— Kunal Chattopadhyay -
Double Standards, Imperial Hypocrisy 25 Years After 9/11 – What Has Changed?
— Val Moghadam -
Fighting Fascism in the Trump Era
— Ken Lawrence -
German Trial of Pro-Palestinian Activists
— Martin Oppenheimer - The Trump-Putin Axis
- Essay
-
The Rise of Democratic Socialists: Democratic Discontent
— Kim Moody - Reviews
-
A Movement’s Inspiration and Legacy
— Francis Shor -
From Movement to State Ideology
— Donald Greenspon -
From Buczacz to Palestine: An Historian's Journey
— David Finkel -
Bolshevik Rule During the Civil War
— Samuel Farber -
Rosa Luxemburg's Radical Ecology
— Paul Le Blanc -
Global Heating on the Ground
— Mike McCallister -
A Chapter of Texas Radicalism
— Folko Mueller -
The Zany Comedy of I Love Boosters
— Frann Michel
Kim Moody

This article was written in advance of the November 2026 elections, but the print edition will reach Against the Current readers after the election in our November-December issue. — The ATC editors
MUCH OF THIS article will focus on the Democratic Socialists of America and an analysis of DSA’s electoral perspectives and results going into the midterm elections.
While there are thousands of DSA members engaged in grassroots organizing in unions, tenant organizations, climate change groups and social movement organizations, the weight of its current growth comes overwhelmingly from its work running — and frequently winning — elections. This can only push DSA further into a central focus on electing socialists as Democrats in hopes of moving the party to the left.
And yet, we’ll argue, despite a general shift to populist rhetoric by political candidates, the barriers to such a strategy are, if anything, greater than ever. If the Democrats gain majority control of the House of Representatives, DSA’s presumptive seven House members — while a big advance for DSA — would be less than three percent of the Democratic Party caucus.
The only things in U.S. politics less well thought of than the Democratic Party, these days, are the cost of living and Donald Trump. So, armed with carefully crafted, generously financed messages about affordability and tales of Trump threats, financial dealing and disasters, the Democrats will most likely take back the House of Representatives and possibly even the Senate.
The contests that will decide the party’s fate in the House, however, will be fought in just 40-or-so “battleground” congressional districts.(1) Despite the well-publicized rebellion by progressives and the impressive victories of a new cohort of democratic socialists, the party’s “establishment” has already determined that in the effort to win control of the House, the candidates who fight these competitive battles will be, with few exceptions, moderates.
The centrists and moderates, of course, have been spruced up with a focus on the economy, a new-found love of the working class, some populist lingo, and even when viable the banner of generational rebellion — but they will be centrists, mostly hand-picked from on high by the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee (DCCC).
The DCCC provides funding and resources for preferred candidates, in consultation with party leaders, donors, key House office holders and consultants. As of July 31, the DCCC had spent $154,468,999 on primary campaigns.(2)
It’s not a conspiracy. It’s how the congressional party has approached competitive districts for years. The DCCC has two programs to accomplish this: the Frontline program for incumbent House members in competitive districts, and the Red to Blue program of candidates for potentially competitive Republican-held districts.
This year there are 30 incumbents in the Frontline program, 24 of whom are members of the House’s centrist New Democrat Coalition (NDC), two rightwing Blue Dogs, and two members of the Congressional Progressive Caucus (CPC), one of whom is also a member of the NDC.
The Red to Blue group consists of 46 candidates, only a few of whom could be considered progressives.(3) Both groups are picked by the DCCC and, if necessary, helped through their primary elections and provided generous campaign resources.
The irony is that while a number of progressives and socialists have become household names, you probably never heard of most of those whose candidacies will determine who wins the House in November.
The Progressive Rebellion and its Limits
Dissatisfaction and disgust with the Democratic Party’s leadership, direction and internal functioning has led to a sizable and well-publicized rebellion on the party’s left. It is a big moment for DSA, as five new democratic socialists are certain to win in November, bringing its House representation to seven.
This electoral revolt, however, was even broader. Not including incumbents, this year 38 presumably progressive primary candidates for the House of Representatives were endorsed by at least one of Bernie Sanders, Our Revolution, Justice Democrats, or the national Democratic Socialists of America (DSA). This compares to about 11 in 2024.(4)
Twenty-three of this year’s candidates won their primaries. This is pretty good considering the millions of dollars thrown against many of them by AIPAC and assorted Democratic billionaire donors and their super PACs.
For example, according to Open Secrets, as of late August “the pro-Israel community has spent $70.8 million on independent expenditures, second only to the crypto industry’s $77.1 million.”(5) Altogether, according to Federal Election Commission (FEC) figures, Democrats spent $761,875,685 fighting each other for office, almost $200,000,000 more than Republicans.(6)
In the end, however, it was not a major cleansing of old guard House members as only seven Democratic incumbents lost their seats (compared to 6 in 2024, 12 in 2022, and 16 in 2020), four of whom were beaten by progressives — including three DSA members.
Overall, only four of the total progressive winners, two of whom were also aligned with moderate organizations, were in battleground districts. So despite the hysteria from some party leaders, advisors and commentators, the left will not hand the Republicans a victory in the House. That will be up to the party’s political center.
The Siege of Troy
THERE ARE SOME left progressive candidates for Senate who won their primaries as well. Notably, Angie Nixon in Florida, Graham Platner in Maine and Abdul El-Sayed in Michigan.
When former logger and Maine State Senator Troy Jackson replaced the disgraced Platner as the Democratic candidate for U.S. Senate in July, he launched a populist campaign that called for Medicate-For-All, an end to military aid to Israel’s genocide in Gaza, free childcare, taxes on the rich, etc.
He planned townhall meetings, door-to-door canvasing by volunteers, local fund-raising events, media interviews, and a lot of face-to-face contact and Q&As with voters in his campaign to defeat Republican Susan Collins. And the volunteers and voters responded enthusiastically. Hey, the Democratic ballot line is just a state-provided form of expression or a tactic. Right?
Before the campaign could even get off the ground, Democratic Party Big Whigs in Washington, including from the party’s Democratic Senate Campaign Committee, invaded Maine with a corps of DC- and New York-based consultants fresh from their losses in the primaries on behalf of Haley Stevens in Michigan, Dan Goldman in New York, and Colin Allred in Texas.
Never mind, these pros knew just what to do. For all practical purposes they took over the campaign and wrote scripts for Jackson that excluded the word “genocide” in reference to Gaza.
They said it was alright to tell voters they could have private health insurance under Troy’s version of Medicare-For-All. They cancelled town hall meetings and Q&A sessions. They sent Troy on a 14-day tour of out-of-state wealthy donors to pay for all the watered-down ads that replaced person-to-person contact. Troy still spoke out at times, but many of his supporter felt betrayed and told him so.* That’s the real Democratic Party.
*Rebecca Traister, “The Accidental Candidate, Intelligencer,” New York Magazine, September 22, 2026. Lists; Nathan Bernard and Ryan Grim, Democratic Party Consultants Surround Troy Jackson with Pro-Israel Donors, September 25, 2026, Dropsitenews+us-poltics@substack.com
But even though most progressives will win the general election since they are in safe Democratic districts, neither will these gains change the balance of political forces in the House much when the 120th Congress convenes in 2027.
This is in part because of the number of retirements and primary defeats of members of the various “ideological” caucuses in the House; in part due to victories by billionaire-backed moderates; in part due to the dubious progressivism of some of those endorsed by Bernie Sanders; and in part to new organization among self-proclaimed moderates.
What then is the likely shift due to changes in the three major ideological caucuses in the current 119th Congress: the centrist New Democratic Coalition (NDC) with 111 members; the Congressional Progressive Caucus (CPC) with 95 members; and the conservative Blue Dogs with 10 members, six of whom also belong to the NDC?
Granted, this is not exactly science. There are some members who don’t belong to a caucus, although most do. Members of the CPC in particular may vary in their commitment to major progressive positions like Medicare-for-All, ending aid to Israel, stopping the war in the Middle East, climate change, etc.
Second, several members of CPC also belong to the centrist NDC, suggesting a rather weak “progressivism.”
With that caveat, here is the basic math. Fifteen Congressional Progressive Caucus members either retired, ran for a different office, or were defeated in the primaries. If all 23 progressives who won their primaries win the general and join the CPC it will increase by eight members.
The centrist NDC, which is significantly larger, lost just eight members due to retirement or defeat. But the newly formed, centrist and billionaire-backed Majority Democrats re-elected most of its 15 incumbent members, and its allied slate “The Bench” sent 10 new moderate members to the general election. We can assume they will mostly join the NDC if they win in November, preventing any net loss.(7)
So at face value there isn’t much of a numerical shift in organized House politics. Furthermore, there is no sign of a change of, or serious challenge to, the militantly centrist leader of the House Democratic Caucus: Hakeem Jeffries. Quite the contrary.
There is, of course, more to a potential political shift than caucus membership. For example, three groups among the 23 successful progressive-endorsed candidates who will go on to the general election are pulling in different directions: four branded as “Bernie-Dogs” by Politico journalists; some elected by the overlapping billionaire-backed Majority Democrats/The Bench; and five members of DSA.
The “Bernie-Dogs” are composed of four Democrats endorsed by both Sanders and the conservative Blue Dog Coalition. These are Bob Brooks (PA 7), Sam Forstag (MT 1), Brian Poindexter (OH 7), and Rebecca Cooke (WI 3).(8) The same four also received the blessing and resources of the DCCC in its Red to Blue program.(9)
This is at least an indication of acceptably moderate progressivism. Two of these dual endorsees are also backed by the anti-left, billionaire-funded “The Bench”— Brooks and Forstag.(10) A seriously bad sign.
The overlapping, militantly moderate Majority Democrats and The Bench were conceived and backed by billionaire hedge fund manager and Democratic donor Stephen Mandel. Majority Democrats is meant to be a “party within a party” that will counter the challenges from the left (by stealing some of its rhetoric) and will bring us “the next generation of Democratic leaders-willing to challenge the establishment and break with party orthodoxy.”
It is further funded by a lineup of big tech, private equity and crypto-donors, and dispenses money through a complex of PACs and Super PACs. Overall, Majority Democrats backed 14 House candidates, mostly incumbents, six of whom ran uncontested, one of whom withdrew (Jared Golden), most of the rest of whom won their primaries. The Bench supported 14 House newcomers, 10 of whom won including Brooks and Forstag.(11)
A look at the policy sections of Bernie Dogs’ websites reveals general and vague statements or limited reforms for improving healthcare, cost of living, better things for working people, fairer taxes, etc, but no commitments to specifics such as Medicare-for-All as a single payer system, Green New Deal, and virtually nothing on Palestine or Iran — in other words, what has become mainstream Democratic semi-populist rhetoric.
What unites them is their working-class and even union backgrounds. That is part of Bernie’s own 2026 extensive effort to save the Democrats from themselves that planted organizers in red or competitive states to find candidates with a populist bent, such as Abdul El-Sayed in Michigan for Senate or Rebecca Cook in Wisconsin and Forstag in Montana for the House.(12)
It’s a different and broader approach than that of DSA, and Bernie’s policy requirements appear much looser. In addition to the vague policy statements of the Bernie Dogs, for example, El-Sayed’s version of Medicare-For-All is not a single-payer plan. His website states, “Medicare for All does not have to ban additional private insurance through unions and employers…”(13) This is what Pete Buttigieg calls “Medicare for All Who Want It,” and would mean continued high administrative costs and a potential two-tier system.(14)
Then there are those DSA candidates whom Sanders didn’t endorse, such as Wisconsin gubernatorial candidate Francesca Hong who nearly won her primary, Oliver Larkin who lost his House bid badly in Florida, and Darializa Avila Chevalier.
On the other side of this coin are the five DSA members who won House primaries in a big gain for DSA: Chris Rabb (PA 3); Melot Kiros (CO 1); Donovan McKinney (MI 13); Claire Valdez (NY 7); and Darializa Avila Chevalier (NY13), who did throw out a long-time party regular (and CPC member) even though he out spent her three-to-one.
All are in safe Democratic districts and will win in November. That will bring the DSA presence in the House to seven — a new high. Once they take office next year, however, they will face enormous barriers to deliver on the promises they made, or even to move the politics of this pro-capitalist and capital-dependent party they have adopted.
What makes the “DSA 7” different from most progressives, however, is not so much the issues and programs most ran on, but that they will have behind them a semi-mass, by now electorally experienced — though politically contradictory — semi-mass organization.
Rise of the New DSA
In less than two years, the DSA has been transformed — again. The first change came when the moribund DSA of 6000 or so of mostly paper members grew rapidly to 94,000 in 2021 in the wake of Sanders’ 2016 and 2020 runs for the Democratic presidential nomination and the election of the first two DSAers to run as open members to the House.(15)
This put DSA on the map and drew in thousands of young activists. The second phase saw DSA membership drop by 30,000 to a low of 64,000 in October 2024 as Democratic politics returned to the status quo under Biden, and the organization experienced internal conflict over DSA congressional member Jamaal Bowman’s vote to fund Israel’s “Iron Dome” and refusal to endorse BDS. (Bowman, an outspoken critic of the Israeli-U.S. genocide in Gaza, lost in the 2024 primary when AIPAC spent $15 million to defeat him.)

Membership growth resumed rapidly with the Mamdani mayoral race, rising from 63,945 in March 2025 to over 93,000 by the end of the year. By the end of July, 2026, it had surpassed 128,000 on the wave of electoral successes.(16)
Indeed, so successful has been DSA’s growth and recent electoral activity it has drawn the attention of New York Times, Cook Political Report, Politico and other liberal media outlets, a House resolution condemning socialism and DSA (with eight Dems voting for), and even a study by the liberal Brookings Institute.
The Brookings study covers 282 candidates endorsed or “recommended” by DSA nationally or by chapters but doesn’t list details. To get a better look at the participation of actual DSA members in running for office it is more useful to use DSA’s National Electoral Commission’s (NEC) tally of DSA members running for office, though not necessarily endorsed by national DSA.(17)
According to the NEC, 175 DSAers ran for office in 2026. Of the 121 whose elections were completed by the end of August, 64 won and 57 lost. Twenty-four ran for the House, no one ran for Senate, and all the rest for local or state office, mostly state legislative seats.
Of the 24 DSAers who ran for the House, seven won their primary. Two of these were incumbents (Rashida Tlaib and Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, who after a seven-year lapse renewed her DSA membership in August),(18) so only five out of 22 challengers won.
Nevertheless, there isn’t much doubt that DSA’s recent soaring membership growth was the result of the string of highly visible, successful elections that began with Zohran Mamdani’s stunning primary victory and ultimate election in the race for New York mayor, followed in 2026 by those of New Yorkers Claire Valdez and Darializa Avila Chevalier for Congress — all as declared members of DSA. These gains in NY were reinforced by wins in PA (Charles Rabb), CO (Melat Kiros), FL (Angie Nixon), RI (David Morales) DC (Janeese Lewis George) and Francesca Hong’s near win in WI, among other prominent races.
The explosion of national membership from 63,945 in March 2025 to 128,973 in July 2026 was clearly the result of its New York mayoral, seven congressional, and 38 (out of 52) successful state legislative campaigns.(19)
The New York City chapter of DSA, which had fallen to under 6000 members in 2023 and lingered around 6500 during 2024, more than doubled its members to nearly 16,000 by July 2026 in the wake of its electoral successes on the basis of a highly developed electoral “machine” able to mobilize thousands of volunteers, though it has built nothing in the way of permanent organization beyond DSA itself.(20)
This growth differs from that following Sanders’ campaigns in 2016 and 2020 in that it is based on DSA’s own candidates, its increased electoral activity and relative success. This means tens of thousands of new members, who view DSA as mainly an electoral movement, are registered Democrats who came to it through Democratic Party primary mobilizations. Despite their anger with the party, they are encouraged by those DSA leaders most involved in electoral action to see the Democratic Party as DSA’s primary practical vehicle for social change.
Some advocate an “inside-outside” strategy where pressure from below is applied to win things, but so far nothing approaching its massive election-time volunteer mobilization has been deployed as “outside” pressure.
For one thing, DSA’s ability to expand its House, mayoral and even state legislative representation is limited by its geographically narrow base. DSA members remain heavily concentrated in less than a dozen large urban areas, all deep blue strongholds.
Out of more than 240 chapters and organizing committees, over a third of DSA’s total growth from March 2025 to July 2026 came from just 11 urban chapters with over 2000 members, over half of that from New York City, Los Angeles and Washington, DC alone.(21)
These are also, of course, the major centers of DSA electoral activity in which a DSAer is either mayor as in NYC, virtually mayor-elect as in DC, or in a close runoff as in LA although (the local DSA chapter was divided over the candidacy of Nithya Raman and did not formally endorse her for the primary but did for the general election). DSAer David Morales won the primary to be mayor of Providence without his chapter’s endorsement. He and his allies will have a majority on Providence’s next city council.(22)
Almost all of these fall within deep blue urban areas. In terms of functioning within Congress or state legislatures, the internal barriers to influence in this capitalist party are, if anything, even greater.
In the House, the DCCC, which plays a central part in candidate support, received some 60% of its $339,935,853 expenditures for 2024 from corporate PACs or donors wealthy enough to give $50,000 or more.(23) By the end of July, 2026 it had raised $210,406,754.(24)
Many House Caucus members depend on this support even beyond whatever funds they raise from the wealthy. More immediate is the power of the Democratic House Caucus (minority/majority) leader who commands a staff of about 100 and disproportionately influences the all-important committee assignments and what legislation makes its way to a floor vote in the House.

The arcane procedures and folkways of the Caucus, and indeed the legislative process itself, are further pressures for partisan conformity on major issues. That is why, despite their popularity, the Green New Deal, Medicare-For-All, serious taxes on the rich, etc, never made it to a floor vote in the House.
It will be impossible to make much progress on the issues without replacing the current House leadership of Hakeem Jeffries, a corporate-AIPAC-funded and firm opponent of socialism, Medicare-for-All, ending aid to Israel, and so on, who raised $15 million for re-election despite facing no real challenge.
Yet the first challenge of the new House members will be the demand by the majority of the caucus for them to vote for Jeffries as Majority leader and hence Speaker of the House once the 120th Congress convenes.
Jeffries did not waste a moment to put up one barrier to the left by appointing Jared Moskowitz, the pro-Israel moderate who beat DSAer Oliver Larkin in the Florida primary, to chair the House Foreign Affairs Subcommittee on the Middle East and North Africa. He will, according to his X posting, “strengthen America’s relationship with Israel and our Gulf allies” assuming the Dems take the House.(25)
The often invisible but nonetheless real interconnected networks of influence, power, and dealings within the Democratic Party as a whole also produce pressures against open rebellion within Congress, or any legislature, from within DSA itself as more of its members hold political office.
Zohran Mamdani’s need to accommodate the state party in order to get funds for the city led him to oppose DSA running a candidate against Jeffries in the primaries, and more recently to publicly state his support for Jeffries as leader and, hence, Speaker of the House.
This effectively precludes any open opposition to Jeffries by the “DSA 7” for the foreseeable future. In fact, although self-defeating in the long run, the past and current DSA members of Congress consistently voted for centrists Nancy Pelosi and Jeffries as caucus leaders to avoid conflict or in hopes of concessions.
AOC says she will vote for Jeffries (again), while so far only Melot Kiros has indicated she would not vote for any leader who takes corporate money, which eliminates Jeffries and many others.(26)
DSA as a Democratic Party “Faction”
On the one hand, the growth of DSA represents and reflects the growth of socialism as a political identity even beyond its own new members. It has brought the idea of socialism, long considered outside the spectrum of American political thought, back into day-to-day conversation — both pro and con.
Its very breadth, like that of many socialist parties of the past from the German Social Democrats, to the old Socialist Party of America, to the Bolsheviks, has suggested that socialism need not be confined to tiny groups. For thousands of activists advancing the labor and social movements on which any real socialist movement must be built, it has provided an organized context in which to build these movements.
Independent Working-Class Candidates
IT’S ALMOST A trend. Tired of the failure of the Democrats to aid working-class people, some union workers are running as independents for the House and Senate.
Dan Osborn, former union and strike leader, who is running a second time for the Senate from Nebraska is the best known. He has set up the Working Class Heroes Fund to support others. Now three others are running for the House and endorsed by the fund: Nate Powell, union firefighter (WA 5); Bill Hill commercial fisherman (AK at large); and union firefighter Mike Thurow (WI 6).
These are white working-class guys running on anti-billionaire, anti-corporate, generally progressive populist platforms in red states or districts where Democrats fear to tread and DSA has little strength. There’s even a chance some may win. How will DSA Democrats relate to them?
In all these ways any socialist should view the growth of DSA as a positive step toward the growth of socialism as a force in the United States. On the other hand, DSA lacks a coherent national leadership that provides a clear direction for the organization as a whole.
DSA’s structure is democratic and allows the regular formation of political caucuses to facilitate open debate. Yet none of these caucuses has more than a few hundred members, so that conventions, leadership bodies and formal debate are dominated by small minorities which themselves lack political agreement on the major direction of the organization.
The lack of a coherent leadership and this anomaly mean that the organization as a whole and its political direction are actually pulled by the practice of the chapters, above all those urban chapters organizing the majority of electoral activities.
As it is now, the chapters decide whether or not and whom to run for what office. Despite the fact that the Democratic Party is despised by many of its loyal voters, running candidates as Democrats is already the most defining activity of DSA.
As new members who joined on the basis of electoral success and hopes of changing the Democrats fill up the major chapters and branches, this electoral practice will become even more central — indeed, the central practice of DSA as a whole.
Marxists judge politicians and organizations by what they do, not what they say. Officially, DSA looks toward a break with the Democrats. Running as Democrats is said to be a “tactic.” But none of its candidates run on such a platform, and most proclaim their loyalty to the party, even when they criticize it or its “establishment,” as pressure intensifies to defeat Trump and the Republicans in the midterm election and in 2028.

For all of DSA’s pluralism, there is no deviation in its electoral practice. Almost no one takes a step toward anything but the Democratic ballot line. It is never time to challenge the centrist leaders much less organize for a break. So in reality, no matter what the convention resolutions or caucuses say, the electoral practice of DSA remains dominant and points toward being a faction in the Democratic Party — indefinitely. The “tactic” becomes the strategy.
What hasn’t been created beyond DSA itself — either by DSA or Bernie Sanders — other than the impressive but temporary election mobilizations in New York or elsewhere, are ongoing independent working class-based political organizations, groups in neighborhoods, unions and other social movement organizations, or even the “party surrogate” that Seth Ackerman proposed a decade ago, “A Blueprint for a New Party,” which could be the basis of an eventual break.
For the foreseeable future, DSA and the electoral left will remain a faction and prisoner of the Democratic Party.
By the time you read this the Democrats may have taken the House and possibly even the Senate, and the race for the presidency will be on.
An AOC run for the Democratic nomination would certainly shake things up and provide an alternative to the dreary pack of centrists fighting to be the opposition to JD Vance, Marco Rubio, Trumpism without Trump, etc. in 2028 — not to mention additional growth for DSA.
But almost inevitably the centrists would unite around one of their own to stop her as they did to stop Bernie in 2020. There is too much at stake not only for the party, but for all the businesses and wealthy that still depend on it for domestic and international stability.
The party can swing a little left or right, produce limited reforms, but it will never be a vehicle for working-class power or socialism. Nor will there ever be a convenient “right time” to take the path to working-class political independence given the persistence of the right.
If it is ever to happen, the time is fast approaching to begin the political turn toward the political independence of the working class.
Notes
- Ballotpedia, U.S. House battlegrounds, 2026, 2026, U.S. House elections, Ballotpedia, https://Ballotpedia.org/U.S._House_battlegrounds_2026; DCCC, 2026 Red to Blue, https://dccc.org/2026-red-to-blue/
back to text - Federal Election Commission, Political action and party committees, DCCC, https://www.fec.gov/data/committees/pac-party/?cycle=2026
back to text - Ballotpedia, U.S. House battlegrounds, 2026, 2026, U.S. House elections, Ballotpedia, https://Ballotpedia.org/U.S._House_battlegrounds_2026; DCCC, 2026 Red to Blue, https://dccc.org/2026-red-to-blue
back to text - Data on endorsements and elections are taken mostly from Ballotpedia; websites of endorsing organizations; and AP election results.
back to text - Jonathan D. Salant, “AIPAC’s super PAC is the top outside spender in 2026, fuelling Democratic rift,” Opensecrets.com, August 27, 2026, https://www.opensecrets.org/news/2026/08/aipacs-super-pac-is-the-top-outside-spender-in-2026-fueling-democratic-rift/?emci=3c788242-53a1-f111-9b33-0022482a9f1d&emdi=3dd761f6-27a2-f111-9b33-0022482a9bea&ceid=28584415
back to text - Federal Election Commission, Spending by the Numbers, 2026, https://www.fec.gov/data/spending-bythenumbers/?office-H
back to text - Luke Goldstein and Katya Schwenk, “The New Democratic Machine — And The Billionaires Behind It,” The Lever, April 24, 2026, https://nymag.com/intelligencer/article/maine-senate-democratic-party-troy-jackson-graham-platner-susan-collins.html?ueid=30a7c8ef1c7093b53bb38933fe63045c&utm_source=Sailthru&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=weekendreader_intel_20260926&utm_term=Smart%20List%20-%20Intel%20Daily%20and%20Weekend%20Lists; Nathan Bernard and Ryan Grim, Democratic Party Consultants Surround Troy Jackson with Pro-Israel Donors, September 25, 2026, Dropsitenews+us-poltics@substack.com.
back to text - Eli Okun, Ali Bianco and Irie Sentner, “Meet the Bernie-Dogs,” Politico, August 16, 2026, https://www.politico.com/newsletters/playbook/2026/08/16/meet-the-bernie-dogs-01038896
back to text - DCCC, Red to Blue.
back to text - The Bench, “Our Candidates,” https://www.thebench.org/candidates/; Luke Goldstein and Katya Schwenk, “There’s a New Dark Money-Backed Democratic Machine,” Jacobin, April 27, 2026, https://jacobin.com/2026/04/democratic-campaigns-finance-dark-money
back to text - Katya Schwenk and Luke Goldstein, “How A Hedge Fund Billionaire Became The Democrats’ New Kingmaker,” The Lever, August 11, 2026, https://www.levernews.com/how-a-hedge-fund-billionaire-became-the-democrats-new-kingmaker/?ref=lever-weekly-newsletter; Goldstein and Schwenk; Majority Democrats (website), About, https://majoritydemocrats.com/about
back to text - Will Steakin, “Bernie Sanders Lets Loose on the Democratic Party, the Midterms and 2028,” Politico, September 6, 2026, https://www.politico.com/news/magazine/2026/09/06/bernie-sanders-democrats-midterms-2028-legacy-01065103
back to text - “Abdul for US Senate, Medicare for All — the path to a healthier America,” https://abdulforsenate.com/priority/medicare-for-all-the-path-to-a-healthier-america/
back to text - Carl Beijer, “Don’t Back Down on Medicare for All,” Jacobin, August 13, 2026, https://jacobin.com/2026/08/medicare-el-sayed-private-health-insurance
back to text - Representatives John Conyers, Major Owen, Ron Delums, and Danny Davis were DSA members but did not run or serve as open members or socialists.
back to text - DSA, [Public] DSA Membership Numbers by Chapter, https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1qWH39PiSmFrj8cGtVwMVVZSM9BarvCakKRSKIStcHE0/edit?gid=0#gid=0
back to text - Nec, DSA elections 2026, accessed August 27, https://2026.electoral.dsausa.org/
back to text - Peter Sterne, “AOC rejoined DSA this month after seven-year absence,” City & State New York, August 26, 2026, https://www.cityandstateny.com/politics/2026/08/aoc-rejoined-dsa-month-after-7-year-absence/415648/?oref=csny-category-lander-featured-river; Fabian Holt, Organize Or Burn: How New York Socialists Fight for Climate Survival, New York University Press, 2025.
back to text - Nec, DSA elections 2026.
back to text - Memberhsip numbers come from DSA’s DSA [Public] Membership Numbers by Chapter, https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1qWH39PiSmFrj8cGtVwMVVZSM9BarvCakKRSKIStcHE0/edit?gid=0#gid=0
back to text - DSA [Public] Membership Numbers by Chapter.
back to text - Promise Li, “LA’s Left-Liberal Electoral Problem,” Spectre, July 7, 2026, https://spectrejournal.com/las-left-liberal-electoral-problem/
back to text - I have written extensively on these limits. See, for example, Kim Moody, Democrats: “The Rise & Fall of the Conglomerate Party of the Center,” New Politics, Vol. XX, No. 4, Winter 2026, 3-20; Kim Moody, Breaking the Impasse: Electoral Politics, Mass Action & The New Socialist Movement in the United States, Chicago: Haymarket Books,2022, 6-60.
back to text - Federal Election Commission, DCCC, financial summary, 01/01/25 to 07/31.2026, https://www.fec.gov/data/committee/C00000935/
back to text - Veronica Riccobene and Jonathan Easley, “Base Baiting,” The Lever, August 27, 2026, by subscription, https://www.levernews.com/
back to text - Oren Schweitzer, “The Democratic Socialists Are Coming to Congress in 2027,” The Call, August 17, 2026, https://socialistcall.com/2026/08/17/the-democratic-socialists-are-coming-to-congress-in-2027/
back to text
November-December 2026, ATC 245


Excellent analysis by the ever-on-the-mark Kim Moody. Thanks for printing this. It should be read and discussed by every socialist working-class organizer, especially those feeling the tremendous pressure to jump into the Democratic Party to support the “just vote blue” call.
Practice has made that statement true. None of the DSA candidates are breaking away. The chapters choose who will run. They will all be democrats by virtue of joining after a primary. Membership grew from 63,945 March 2025 to 128,973 in July of 2026. Over a third of that membership increase came from 11 urban chapters. If someone replies without addressing these figures they’re just being evasive. Another good argument he makes is that DSA will take its cues from the direction of it’s large chapters. Not its leadership or its various caucuses which number in the hundreds. Again a statement that can be addressed factually about how decisions are made within DSA.
There is no agent. “Time is quickly drawing near” there is no indication of an actor taking the first steps. Or what signs will indicate time is near. He outlines a series of organizations that haven’t been formed yet. Independent workers organizations. A surrogate for Ackermans party. Who is going to form these? Will dsa help form these organizations or is it getting in the way?
His sidebar on running independents (Osborn, Powell, Hill and Thurow) is the only mention of independence in his article. How will dsa democrats act toward these individuals? He doesn’t say. All of these locations are in Red districts and where dsa has little presence. So independence is taking place outside of dsa. He states that dsa is broad by referencing it’s similarity to the SPD, SPA and the Bolsheviks. He says a lack of coherent leadership around this broadness will steer the organization the wrong way. What coherent leadership looks like or how we can obtain that he doesn’t say.
Troy Jackson isn’t DSA. When you look at the situation in Maine we see the National Machine stepping in and trying to control the campaign. However with dsa 7 in a district with low competition we can see where the push is coming from with Moody. A vote to support Jeffries and accommodating Mamdani. Consultation from a consultant won’t drive dsa in these districts.
There are grains of truth in Kim’s piece. I confess I don’t know enough about every situation to comment on all of DSA. But it strikes me as relying very heavily on secondhand reporting and statistics without a feel for the real tensions within DSA and the context in which DSA is operating nationally. So, I’ll just comment on what I know best.
The sidebar on Troy rings hollow. I live Maine, been volunteering for Troy for more than a year, he has endorsed my campaign for Portland City Council, everyone I know supports Troy, etc., etc. Kim lists 10% of the facts (really just takes a swing at Troy) and misses 90% of the story. Nurses, shipyard workers, public employees, grad students, and more are all in on Troy. Huge canvass turnouts, town halls, unscripted Q&As, AOC, Bernie, etc. hammering on the billionaires. It’s a tough fight because he’s being outspent vastly by Collins (yes, he left the state for a few days to raise money–V.I. on robbers…) but he’s got enough money to be competitive. His main strength is labor and his main weakness is how badly the bosses have beaten up labor for decades. Troy’s campaign is driven by exactly those parts of the Maine labor movement that want to fight and develop their own political program. His campaign is making a significant contribution to Maine labor’s self-confidence and helping expand a core of organizers who will keep fighting after Nov. 3. The former mill towns are the toughest to win because they were defeated by the bosses. But Troy gets more of a hearing than any “pickup truck progressive” has in decades. It’s an important shift.
By way of comparison, Troy has qualitatively more labor support than RPA ever did. I will admit I was wrong at the time about RPA. Mike Parker and Kim Moody were right to support that coalition with Dems (yes, Dems) and Greens. I repeat, I was wrong. I mistook form for content. I can’t go back in time, but I don’t have to make the same mistake again. I think Kim is doing the same thing I did back then in this article based on very little information about what is actually happening in Maine. Yes, the corporate Dems are in, but it’s remarkable how clear Troy has remained to his principles and his friends. It’s a small state. Everyone knows each other. It’s a fight. En s’engage et puis on voit.
BTW, Collins is saying the most vile shit about Troy’s family. It’s scorched earth.
Finally, international affairs are not Troy’s strong suit. He’s hardly ever left Maine. He did get pushed by the corporate Dems (and some local Dem figures) to tone down his statements on Gaza. He doesn’t always focus on Gaza (more on Iran these days), but he has not backed down. Here’s what his website currently: “End the genocide in Gaza and stop U.S. funding for Israel’s military
Troy believes what’s happening in Gaza is a genocide, that Benjamin Netanyahu is a war criminal, and the U.S. government has a responsibility to not enable that suffering.”
And it’s not just on his website. He says it’s genocide on TV and he says it at town halls.
I’m not saying everything is perfect. But there’s more here in Maine to see than this article lets on.
After Nov. 3, it would be good to assess the results.
In solidarity,
Todd
Kim Moody was unable to post a response to Todd’s comment but he sent it to the ATC editors to post for him:
I’m surprised that Todd Chretien saw the side bar in my article as an attack on Troy Jackson as it is clearly meant as a critique of the Democratic Party establishment, the Democratic Senate Campaign Committee, their one note consultants, and their ham-fisted attempt to take over his campaign. It was meant as an illustration of the fact that the Democratic Party ballot line involves a great deal more than many on the left seem to realize. In the past I have emphasized that it is the path to the wealth- and centrist-dominated reality of political office as a Democrat. But it has become more and more obvious that the party’s rulers intervene early and often in various ways to prevent any serious move to the left that would alienate not only their wealthy donors but capital in general. For a more detailed account of just what this party of capital is composed of I recommend my fairly recent article in New Politics, available on their website at https://newpol.org/issue_post/democrats/.
Moody believes that the Democratic Party will never give the working class power. There will never be a good time to make a change, and the time is coming to make that change. But who is he telling to make the turn? He lists what is missing from our current socialist movement: working-class political movements that are independent, movements at the community/union level, and a “Party Surrogate.” This was a theory Seth Ackerman wrote about in his Jacobin article. ¹⁸ There needs to be a body that can create programs for these future members and allow them to run on any ballot line they see fit. Moody does not state who will be making this change. He only states that the DSA does not have coherent leadership. What would coherent leadership look like, and how would we achieve that?
Moody spent his last book talking about this problem. ¹⁹ I don’t think he can come up with a solution because we have yet to create this organization. Many people have written about why the DSA is not going to create change, and I have included my thoughts on that as well. We need to find who will lead the movement that will take us away from the Democratic Party. There will not be a moment when the DSA wakes up and decides to move toward working-class independence.
I believe that Moody compares the breadth of the DSA to other socialist parties of the past, such as the German Social Democratic Party and the Socialist Party of America, led by Eugene Debs. These were large organizations with many different members who shared a common goal. They created cultural institutions such as newspapers, social clubs, sports teams, and schools. All of which were funded by their members and were part of their party. They had representatives that their party could vote out. Which I think is what is missing from the DSA. They have a breadth of members but no way to control them. Once the DSA grows, they will create leadership that allows them to continue recruiting members. No matter how the convention votes, we will see more Democrats elected and the DSA grow.
In 1971, Hal Draper created the idea of a political center. A political center would not try to create a party but instead help educate and create movements that could lead to one in the future. I think that the DSA has already outgrown the need for a political center. They have 128,000 members who will vote in the Democratic primary. I believe we need to start creating political centers that can help us organize under the DSA. Once we have that, we can start pushing for our own ballot line.
I am currently involved with the Campaign for a Socialist Party. We believe that we need to build towards having a socialist party. We are currently building our movement to be more of a civil society movement. This is what our previous socialist parties used to do. We read many authors who discuss these ideas, but we do not have an answer to Moody’s question. I hope that our organization can continue to grow and help build a working-class political movement.
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1Ijgd2G8yoe-2WF8cABOnV3iSa8-OUkz5EvJM9M8Jz8s/edit?usp=sharing