Against the Current, No. 173, November/
The Middle East's "World War"
— The Editors
Why a Killer Cop Is Not Arrested
— Malik Miah
Two Years After the CTU Strike
— Robert Bartlett
Mass Incarceration and the Left
— Heather Ann Thompson
What September 21st Showed
— Dianne Feeley
Family Planning and the Environment
— Anne Hendrixson
Egypt: Protesting Injustice
— Noha Radwan
Mahienour al-Masry: Icon of a Revolution
— Noha Radwan
- The Purge of Steven Salaita
From Sykes-Picot to "Islamic State": Imperialism's Bloody Wreckage
— Yassamine Mather
LGBT Activism in Mainland China
— Holly Hou Lixian
- Hong Kong's Umbrella Upheaval
The Two-Party System, Part I
— Mark A. Lause
Literature in the Shadows
— Bill V. Mullen
— Matthew Garrett
AIDS Then and Now: A Blood-Drenched Battlefield
— Peter Drucker
Documenting European Socialism
— Ingo Schmidt
Louis Althusser & Academic Marxism
— Nathaniel Mills
- In Memoriam
Ruby Dee, 1922-2014
— Judith E. Smith
Claudia Morcum, Civil Rights Righter
— Dianne Feeley & David Finkel
Notes to Our Readers
— The Editors
NEARLY TWO TIMES a week in the United States a white police officer kills a Black person during a seven-year period ending in 2012, according to the most recent accounts of justifiable homicide reported to the FBI.
“While the racial analysis is striking, the database it’s based on has been long considered flawed and largely incomplete. The killings are self-reported by law enforcement and not all police departments participate, so the database undercounts the actual number of deaths…(T)he numbers are not audited after they are submitted to the FBI and the statistics on ‘justifiable’ homicides have conflicted with independent measures of fatalities at the hands of police.” (USA Today, August 15)
Darren Wilson, the killer of unarmed African-American teenager Michael Brown in Ferguson, Missouri on August 9, continues to receive full pay and freedom. At the Ferguson police department many cops are wearing “I am Darren Wilson” bracelets to mock the chants of Black men and women who chant “I am Michael Brown” at city council meetings and on the street.
Cops and prosecutors assume that Wilson used “reasonable force” and only faces scrutiny because of the public outrage and protests. The struggle is between the historical pattern of African Americans shot by white cops, and the collective fightback to win justice. It is far from settled who will win this tug of war.
A 12-person grand jury was convened on August 20. Grand jury deliberations are secret, but generally follow the direction of the prosecuting attorney. St. Louis County Prosecuting Attorney Robert McCulloch has deep ties to the police, and has favored law enforcement in criminal cases. In his view cops always use “reasonable force” in doing their job.
Although the grand jury began meeting in August, it now reports it may not be able to decide until January whether Wilson should be indicted. On September 16, Wilson testified before the grand jury for more than four hours, and according to sources with knowledge of the investigation Wilson was “cooperative.” He was not obligated to testify.
It takes at least nine of the 12 grand jurors to issue an indictment. A tweet in late September by someone who knows a person on the jury said there is no evidence yet to indict. This leak is a violation of the law and could lead to a new panel of jurors. The chief prosecutor said all evidence will be made public if there is no indictment.
Claim of Self-Defense
The grand jury must be convinced that Wilson wasn’t acting in self-defense (his claim) to make an indictment. Yet it does not have to call eyewitnesses or have an open hearing. Generally the cop declaring self-defense is the only “witness” testifying to the jury. The dead victim is voiceless.
The grand jury system is not democratic or fair. What’s happening here is a classic case of turning the victim into the criminal, and the white killer cop into the “victim.” Where is the required police report after the shooting? In violation of Missouri Sunshine statutes, no information from the police (an incident report, for instance) has been made public).
Wilson has been kept out of the public eye as his mostly white and conservative supporters denounce the protesters as “thugs” and Michael Brown as responsible for his own death. At protests in Ferguson since August 9, it’s been the cops who are violent and disrespectful to mostly peaceful protesters demanding justice for Brown.
Police propaganda and corporate media are spreading the idea that if no indictment is issued, there may be “riots” by the community. The rightwing and racist press (Fox news and conservative blogs) are running defense efforts and public support for Wilson. (See Conservativebyte.com, September 25 that praised cops wearing the “I am Darren Wilson” bracelets.) More money has been raised for the Wilson Defense fund than for the Brown family.
Attorney General Eric Holder and the Department of Justice promised to launch a civil rights investigation. So far little has been done. The DOJ investigation of Trayvon Martin’s killing in Florida has led to no federal indictment of George Zimmerman.
The arrogance of the Ferguson police was on display on September 25 when Chief Tom Jackson issued a video apology to the parents of Michael Brown — six weeks after the killing — that backfired. Jackson told the press he had been too busy working on the case and other aspects of his job to do so earlier.
Evidently the “apology” gambit came from a newly hired public relations firm). Brown’s parents responded to the apology by demanding that the Justice Department take over the case and arrest Wilson.
African Americans are disproportionately arrested, convicted and incarcerated because of the institutional racism of the justice system. Every Black male knows that being Black in itself can lead to your death if a cop decides you are guilty of unknown crimes. You raise your hands (as Brown did) but it doesn’t matter.
The NAACP has issued Born Suspect: Stop-and-Frisk Abuses & the Continued Fight to End Racial Profiling in America, a report that looks at the 20 states without laws explicitly prohibiting racial profiling and the 30 with some form of racial profiling laws on the books. [See http://www.naacp.org/pages/born-suspect-stop-and-frisk-abuses-the-continued-fight-to-end-racial-profil.]
“‘Not much has changed’ in the past decade, said Niaz Kasravi, the report’s lead author and the NAACP’s director of criminal justice. ‘I can’t tell you how many parents have sat with me in their living rooms and talked about their sons or daughters who are no longer with us and flipped through photo albums. It’s heart wrenching.’” (USA Today, September 15)
What happens next in Ferguson depends on the national and international spotlight. Reverend Al Sharpton of the National Action Network, and an adviser to the Brown parents, summarizes best what must be done, “Whether they wear blue jeans or blue uniforms, criminals must be held accountable.”
Collective pushback through civil disobedience and mass public actions is essential to hold the killer cop accountable.
November/December 2014, ATC 173