Who Said Detroit Died?

Against the Current, No. 74, May/June 1998

Eddie Hejka

I LIVE IN a racially-mixed, predominantly African American, community-oriented safe neighborhood. We know all our neighbors. Our children attend good public schools. They participate in neighborhood little league, soccer, art classes and various other activities.

Our oldest child has autism and is looked after, not only by family but also by caring children and adults throughout our community. We couldn’t imagine a nicer place to live and raise a family.

Where is this place, you ask? It’s in Detroit. Despite Heather Thompson’s declaration of Detroit’s death (in ATC 72, January-February 1998, 39-41, reviewing Thomas J. Sugrue’s The Origins of Urban Crisis: Race and Inequality in Postwar Detroit), the city continues on with dozens of thriving communities, rising property values, declining unemployment, lower crime and a sense of optimism that she and others who “romanticize” oppression fail to share.

Aside from differing with her pessimistic perspective on Detroit, I disagree with her recounting of the facts. The nearly quarter million white residents of Detroit (1990 census) would be surprised to learn from her that “virtually all whites had fled Detroit” by 1980.

Her quote of Professor Sugrue saying Detroit was “dominated by rotting hulks of factory buildings closed and abandoned” by 1960 is equally ridiculous. Likewise her own statement, that “whites experienced…[a] devastating and irrevocable loss” when Mayor Coleman Young was elected in 1973, overlooks the significant percentage of white voters who supported him in that first election.

None of this takes away from the factual recounting of the resistance of many white homeowners to integration, or the pervasiveness of racism then and now. Thompson’s choice to group all white residents into stereotypical homogeneous groups, however, contributes to the racism we’d all like to see erased.

White residents are described by Thompson in militaristic terms throughout: They waged “block by block trench warfare battles” over neighborhoods and “finally withdrew their troops from the battlefield for good” with the election of Mayor Young.

African Americans are equally stereotyped. Black residents of Detroit are referred to either as members of the “underclass” (a term I despise as inaccurate and demeaning) or underestimated “challengers” of the status quo whose “power, activism and resilience” and militancy are de-personified and admired.

These stereotypes are bolstered by Thompson’s use of “whites” and “Blacks” as nouns. None of us are simply “a white” or “a Black.” Undoubtedly in this racist society our color affects nearly everything. But is not all that we are: men, women, husbands, fathers, wives, mothers, neighbors, family, friends, enemies and all the other roles that all people play.

Sadly it seems that even with all our good intentions, “progressive” folks are just as likely to believe racial stereotypes as conservatives.

I think that if we want to fight racism, as Heather Thompson surely does, we should begin by looking in our address books. If nearly everyone in there is the same race as ourselves, then it is we who are contributing to racism’s continued strength (not some evil person or persons “out there).

We each have the power to make our communities stronger, and racism weaker, by reaching out and seeing one another as people. Though it seems simple and naive, we’ll find that the next time we look our circle of friends, our communities, our unions, our employees, our churches and our coalitions are more racially-mixed and thereby stronger.

I feel, in my heart, that the racist stereotypes that hurt Detroit and the rest of our communities have to first be addressed personally, because if individuals change then institutions will follow.

ATC 74, May-June 1998


  1. Mr. Hejka mentions the significant number of white people that voted for Coleman Young.First of all he wasn’t old enough to vote in 1973.Secondly if you look at the results of the 1973 Detroit Mayoral election you will see that Mr. Young received the same percentage of the vote that the black population was in Detroit at the time. If a significant amount of white people voted for Coleman Young, than an equally significant amount of black people must have voted for John Nichols. Mr. Nichols was the police commisioner at the time and there was the Stop The Robberies Enjoy Safe Streets STRESS police units that were killing black people operating as a decoy cops. I hardly think that Nichols received even 1% of the black vote much less the significant amount it would take to offset the significant amount of white voters who supposedly voted for Coleman Young.The only way that we as a nation will beat racism is by being honest. For Mr. Hejka to suggest that there were significant amounts of white people who voted for Coleman A.Young is just not being honest.

Comments are closed.